Early in his term Idaho Gov. Butch Otter was close to being forced by water law to send in the National Guard to make farmers dry up tens of thousands of acres.
Drought and a dispute over the water in the Eastern Snake River Plain Aquifer pitted the farmers who irrigated their crops with groundwater against trout farmers who used springs that flowed from the aquifer. The trout farmers had earlier water rights and therefore they were superior.
So unless the groundwater-pumping farmers could come up with an alternative, the fish farmers had first call on the water that was irrigating hundreds of millions of dollars of crops a year. Since then a series of court cases, a lot of talks between the users, and the purchase of the Pristine Springs hatchery in 2008 reduced the conflict.
Otter told the Idaho Press Club this morning the Pristine Springs sale resolved many of the senior right holder’s demands. That prevented drying up 30,000 acres when the pumpers agreed to pay back an Idaho Water Board $11 million loan to free up 10 cubic feet per second of spring flows.
Now the purchase of the Idaho Trout Co. and its water rights next month will complete the transactions that the Otter administration can consider one of the major accomplishments of his governorship. He did this without appointing a director of water resources to run the agency that most observers consider is understaffed and under funded.
The acting director Gary Spackman has served in this position since 2009. Otter told the press before the session he planned to fill the position with a permanent director this year, saying the Water Board wanted a role in the hiring.
The final issue is resolving a dispute of some Upper Snake River Valley farmers who believe the state should pay them for the incidental recharge that happens when they run water in their canals. Otter said he doesn’t think they should be paid, a view of most water lawyers and many downstream farmers who would be forced to pay.
Otter said despite strong area support, rebuilding of the Teton Dam was “problematic.” Instead he talked about adding six feet to existing dams in the state so their reservoir could hold more water as a storage solution.
And he pitched the reporters on the value of building Galloway Dam on the flood-prone Weiser River. On top of reducing floods the water could be used to flush salmon down the Snake and because it’s colder water Otter said it could help Idaho Power meet temperature limits designed to help salmon.
“I think a lot of good tings could happen with that,” he said.
But he acknowledged that would put a lot of private property under water. And he didn’t come up with any ideas for paying for it.

Delicious
Digg
Yahoo
This might be a crazy idea
Wouldn't it be cheaper to move the fish farms up on the rim of the canyon, and water the farmers crops with the effluent? It would solve the water use problem, and would help keep all the fish crap out of the river. Seems like a win/win to me. You know, instead of just fighting all the time and polluting the river.
Anyway, it's something farmers do in 3rd world countries. Works great when you do it right.
Truth is hard to come by
You're right, that is crazy... and no is the answer
Setting aside legal issues related to the water rights there are a couple of technical reasons. First, the fish hatcheries operate 24/7/365. Water for crops is only pumped from the aquifer during the growing season and then only intermitently from a large number of relatively small wells (relative to the flow through a typical hatchery). Second, moving the hatcheries would cost 100's of millions and then they would no longer be taking advantage of the remaining water flowing from the springs.
I'm not sure how "many" senior water rights holder demands were satisfied by either the Pristine or Idaho Trout company deals. Clearly those deals provided a means of satisfying the demands of the two largest spring water users and were perhpas steps in the right direction. Unless there is a yet unanounced plan to satisfy the infringed upon water rights of the relatively large number of smaller spring water users though it is hard to see how "many of the senior rights holders demands" have been met.
But you'll only trip the ACME 700 lb anvil.
----------
Websites: Everytime you get it the way you're comfortable with somebody gives a monkey a rock, bottle and a dollar.
Temperature control at Brownlee Dam needed for Idaho salmon
Rocky,
Good for you for being suspicious of Governor Otter's contention regarding salmon benefits, "And he pitched the reporters on the value of building Galloway Dam on the flood-prone Weiser River. On top of reducing floods the water could be used to flush salmon down the Snake and because it’s colder water Otter said it could help Idaho Power meet temperature limits designed to help salmon."
Water coming out of Idaho Power's Brownlee Dam comes from near the surface of the reservoir and being solar-heated is warm. The cold water of the reservoir, where ever it arrives from, is denser and lies deeper in the reservoir, below the metalimnion. Without a temperature control structure at Brownlee Dam, nothing we do upstream will improve the temperature downstream. To suggest otherwise is misinformed.
I have been pressing this issue with Idaho Power officials, State Legislators and salmon advocacy groups but to no avail. Of course, Governor "Butch" Otter is much more influential than I. Perhaps this post will cross his desk and he will find the nerve to act on the matter so as to benefit Idaho's Salmon. There is already plenty of cold water in Brownlee reservoir to significantly lower temperatures in the Lower Snake River dams downstream. But to date, neither Idaho Power nor Idaho State are willing to move on the effort. Meanwhile I remain perplexed. Apparently lip service is preferred over real action.
Michael Wells has more to say on this topic, in his Salmon Blog, "What Will the Weiser-Galloway Dam Do for Salmon Recovery? Nothing" (see mirror post at http://www.bluefish.org/weiserno.htm)
Put down the crack pipe!
If the governor thinks building a new dam on the Weiser is going to supply cold water to Hells Canyon, he's delusional. Instead, the Snake River will get another infusion of hot, nutrient laden water that will only add to the current water quality issues in Brownlee.
It's still a locomotive...
----------
Websites: Everytime you get it the way you're comfortable with somebody gives a monkey a rock, bottle and a dollar.