Andrus names his candidates for 'greatest' Idaho governors: Batt, Evans and Smylie

Former Gov. Cecil Andrus opened his remarks at Thursday's
City Club of Boise forum distancing himself from the claim of his former press secretary, Chris Carlson, that Andrus is Idaho's "greatest governor."

Andrus and Carlson appeared to discuss Carlson's new memoir, "Cecil Andrus: Idaho's Greatest Governor," which has prompted a good deal of debate about who is worthy of the title.

Before Andrus answered the first question posed by moderator Marty Peterson, Andrus asked for time for what he called a "disclaimer."

"This is Carlson's book, not mine," Andrus said, "and I took offense at the cover and the title, you know, 'The Greatest Governor.' What an arrogant sounding, conceited title."

Andrus, a Democrat, then suggested three contenders for the "greatest" moniker: Republicans Phil Batt and Bob Smylie and Democrat John Evans.

"Phil Batt's children, I've known them, they could say their dad was (greatest). John V. Evans, Jr., could talk about his dad in the mid-1980s facing some very difficult times and he being the greatest. I happen to agree with Steve Smylie...Bob was a three term governor, was successful."

Steve Smylie is Gov. Smylie's son and wrote of his take on the "greatest" controversy in an email to me last month, which I later included in a column.

"I just wanted Steve to know that I agree with his comments that his father should have been included," Andrus said.

"I think everybody thinks their father is the greatest, and that's the way it should be."

Andrus calls Carlson a "surrogate son." He said he confronted Carlson about the title and Carlson replied: "'Then it'll be controversial and I can sell more of my books.'"

You can follow Idaho Statesman Politics on Twitter.

1320962271 Andrus names his candidates for 'greatest' Idaho governors: Batt, Evans and Smylie Idaho Statesman Copyright 2014 Idaho Statesman . All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

None of the above.


Everybody wants to hue the knurled

Best ever......... Cece Andrus by a mile.

Cece Andrus is in a class by himself. Course so are Dork and Butchie.

Class Act

The best City Club I have attended. Wish there were more like him. When he was running the State we didn't have corruption at every level of state government. He is the best of the best.

His comments about Chigbrow, McGee, Hart and Luna were right on.


Really Gov. Andrus...Phil Batt?

No Otter?

The far right is going to cry that Butchie isn't on there.

This is weak Popkey

Just showing up for a free lunch, huh? There was so much good material from today's City Club discussion with Andrus and this is what you choose to write about? I hope you man up and take on some of the tough issues like Cecil did today.

Frank Steunenberg

Union busting Democrat!!!! :D

Such tough work they killed him for it.


Everybody wants to hue the knurled