Salmon debate heats up with summer temperatures
If you think this summer is hot for you consider the salmon and steelhead making their epic odyssey up the Columbia River heading home to Idaho.
Water temperatures exceeded 73 degrees, far warmer than the 68-70 degrees fishery managers say these cold water fish prefer this time of the year. The Clean Water Act requires temperatures 68 degrees and lower.
When temperatures rise to 72 degrees, salmon suffer unless they can find cold water refuges like the mouths of cold water stream like the Deschutes in Oregon or the White Salmon in Washington that come right out of the high country.
Water temperatures usually rise fast in July and peak in early August so this is the critical time in the migration for Snake River steelhead and fall Chinook. Often the steelhead in particular just hang in the cool refuge waters until the water cools off in September.
Research shows predation on fall salmon smolts increases during the warmer temperatures and already biologists have seen fall Chinook adapt their migration behavior to actually wait until the following spring to migrate.
This is not only a problem for the Columbia, which has dams all the way up its tributaries. The Fraser River in British Columbia has no dams and is expected to see it water temperature rise to 72 degrees this month.
That would be the highest temperature ever measured for the river in 100 years of collecting data, according to the newsletter Clearing Up.
Fish managers are doing what they can but they don’t have many options. They have increased releases of the 43-degree water from Dworshak Reservoir in an effort to cool the Snake River.
But 74 degree water was flowing out of Idaho Power’s Brownlee reservoir and in much higher flows to take meet the desires of we Idahoans to power our big screen televisions and air conditioners.
Up to 17 percent of the fall chinook collected at McNary Dam for barging downriver – about 18,000 fish -- died, Clearing Up reported.
What does all this mean?
Researchers found that the average temperature of the Columbia River at Bonneville Dam has risen 1 degree since 1960. If the forecasts are accurate it will rise another degree or more in the next 40 years.
That means the steelhead and fall Chinook must adapt or die, said noted salmon biologist Don Chapman of McCall.
“The steelhead are going to have to adapt to by moving in later or earlier,” Chapman said. “The fish that come in at the same time aren’t going to survive.”
The rising temperatures also means the pressure on Idaho Power to find a way to reduce the temperatures of the water coming out of Brownlee is going to increase, not drop.
That will likely add to our power bills one way or the other.
- Rocky Barker's blog
- Login or register to post comments

Delicious
Digg
Yahoo
Heat Wave
the 68-70 degrees fishery managers say these cold water fish prefer this time of the year. The Clean Water Act requires temperatures 68 degrees and lower.
****
Does this make sense to ANYONE other than Barker?
The fish prefer 68-70 degree.
Yet the CWA "requires" something OUT of their preference zone.
And on the 7th day fish were created in 69 degree water
“The steelhead are going to have to adapt to by moving in later or earlier,” Chapman said. “The fish that come in at the same time aren’t going to survive.”
***
Funny that the fish biologist doesn't think they can "adapt" to higher temperature water.
Yeah, evolution sucks especially when you're a sturgeon.
Hmm. I wonder what the salmon did during the last ice age.
Adapt, swim, or die (or cash your government check)
Udapimp:
Not only do certain fish biologists seem incapable of understanding adaptability of vertebrates that lay billions of eggs a year, they also seem to have a similarly hard time with the concept of "swimming."
As a young child, more than 50 years ago, I regularly fished the creek in back of my grandparent's home in Cougar, Washington. It was easy to find the fish because they began clustering at the bottom of the deeper holes, in the shade of logs, or in the cooler waters under th bank. Even a Kingfisher knows that. Fish swim to preferable habitat or (particularly in dry years) they die -- and more often via predation than overheating in my observations.
Leave it to the government to attempt to regulate stream temperatures based on supposed preferences of a few favored species. I continue to think they place their thermometers in the exact wrong places, and thus come up with policies they've pulled from their thermometer locations. That, and they don't seem to want to know about basic survival concepts such as adaptability and mobility.
Why do we pay these people? Why do we listen to them? Just because they cash our checks? Even kids and birdbrains know better.
Are they using Energy Star rated water coolers for them?
----------
There is no life in Idaho...it is a mirror site on god's server. You were dreaming but it is over. Go to your residence and await our commands and THEN we will restore control...
It means this: It was BLOODY HOT and NO RAIN. OY!
----------
There is no life in Idaho...it is a mirror site on god's server. You were dreaming but it is over. Go to your residence and await our commands and THEN we will restore control...
How many dams have been added?
"Researchers found that the average temperature of the Columbia River at Bonneville Dam has risen 1 degree since 1960. If the forecasts are accurate it will rise another degree or more in the next 40 years."
How much of the one degree change is due to the many dams aded to the Snake River system since 1960?
How much could the temperature be reduced by removing the four Lower Snake River dams?
Seems like every year at his time we hear this same story (I've lived here for 29 years), and some years the steelhead runs are good and some years they are not.
We need more information for this story to have any real meaning.
Good questions and reliable observations
Rocky:
Take note! The writer didn't even mention Global Warming once. I only wish our government wildlife biologists were this thoughtful and observant, and our media journalists this rational and considerate.
Unfortunately, though, our agency scientists and public media seem to need an Apocalypse somewhere in the equation in order to get involved. I'm guessing birddog2 is neither. Unfortunately.
Add lemon, butter and chives and quit whining.
----------
There is no life in Idaho...it is a mirror site on god's server. You were dreaming but it is over. Go to your residence and await our commands and THEN we will restore control...
Hot water
Has anyone addressed the issue of "let it burn" and the loss of tree cover that shades the streams that eventually flow into the big river?