- IdahoStatesman.com
- Blogs
- Bronco Beat
- Murph's Turf
- Varsity Extra
- Idaho Newsreader
- Inside Idaho Business
- Commentary: Kevin Richert
- Your Local Government
- Letters from the West
- Into the Outdoors
- Words & Deeds
- The Beer Nut: Patrick Orr
- What's Online
- Nonprofits
- TechIdaho
- The Cinemaniac
- Idaho Politics: LiCalzi
- Idaho Legislature: Labrador
- Idaho Legislature: Langhorst
- Forums
- Recent Posts
- Content
Boise bisected
Submitted by Kevin Richert on Mon, 08/25/2008 - 11:29am.
It appears that during the past week — when I combined a little late summer vacationing with the decidedly bittersweet experience of driving my oldest son to his freshman year of college — I was AWOL for the political dog days.
The big debate of the past week centered on where Republican 1st District Rep. Bill Sali has set up his office, and where Democratic challenger Walt Minnick calls home. Critics keep pounding Sali for renting office space in Downtown Boise, in the 2nd Congressional District. Republicans alleged — erroneously, according to the Associated Press — that Minnick claimed a property tax exemption this year for a home he occupies in the 2nd District.
Sloppy research on the GOP's part, but this whole hoo-ha doesn't really advance the dialogue on issues. Kudos to Lewiston Tribune editorial page editor Jim Fisher; in a weekend editorial, he called out both parties for focusing on trivia.
As long as we're on this non-topic, though, let's look at it from another angle. This is a symptom of a larger dysfunction: congressional district lines that cut through the largest city of the state.
The political interests of Boise east of Cole Road — and the 2nd Congressional District — are no different than the interests of the western half of Boise. And by dividing Boise between two congressional districts, Boise voters' clout is diminished.
There's no easy solution, but here's something to file away. The day will come — sooner than many Idahoans realize — when the Treasure Valley will warrant its own congressional district.
Other Western states have congressional districts designed largely to serve their preeminent metro areas, such as Denver, Las Vegas and Albuquerque, N.M. It makes sense, since the needs of an urban district are going to be considerably different than the needs of a rural district. I could see real advantages to having a member of the U.S. House of Representatives focused on the unique issues facing the Treasure Valley, starting with highways, public transportation and air quality.
I'm hard-pressed to make the map work, though, at least for now. I could draw up a congressional district comprising 10 Southwest Idaho counties — Ada, Adams, Boise, Canyon, Elmore, Gem, Owyhee, Payette, Washington and Valley. But according to the latest Census Bureau figures, these counties' 654,390 residents account for only 43.6 percent of the state's population. That leaves one House member to represent 56.4 percent of the population, and a district stretching from the Utah-Idaho border to Canada.
No, this isn't the time for a change. The ideal time to set up a Treasure Valley district would be after the state's overall population earns Idaho a third House seat — allowing Idaho to set up districts centered roughly around the Treasure Valley, North Idaho and Eastern Idaho.
But if Ada and Canyon counties continue to grow, relative to the rest of Idaho, the Valley will someday account for half of Idaho's population. When that happens, the Valley should have a standalone congressional district, even if it is one of only two districts in Idaho. The transition will be awkward — but no more awkward than continuing to draw up boundaries that bisect Boise.
»
- Kevin Richert's blog
- Login or register to post comments

Delicious
Digg
Yahoo
I thought one of the 'hidden' motivations was to split
the Democratic stronghold of Boise into 2 districts. Not like it doesn't happen in nearly every other state (Dems & Repubs alike). Silly politicians, democracy is for the people, (he naively said).
"No, this isn't the time for a change."
Hey KR, welcome back and congrats on getting your son off to college.
Your vacation also seems to have earned you some "Right" - mindedness regarding change. Can I take your statement as the paper's endorsement of Rep. Sali, and John McCain? (smile)
MT
That's McClatcy's biz...
and editors gon't changes horses in mid stream for tired ones.
What about
Boise Ada Elmore Owyhee. That seems fair. What's unfair is that Dems in Idaho are completely disenfranchised.
Disenfranchised?
You mean they don't let Democrats vote in Idaho? Or do you mean that even if the congressional districts were gerrymandered beyond belief, there would still be a Republican majority in each one? Because one is disenfranchisement and one is just plain old demographics.
Shucks, Democrats get elected to the legislature. We've even had Democrats in the Governor's and Lieutenant Governor's offices. What about Frank Church? And this election, there's a pretty good chance for a Democrat to unseat a Republican in Congress.
That's disenfranchised?
Jim Fisher did call him on it.
but this wasn't it--"The big debate of the past week centered on where Republican 1st District Rep. Bill Sali has set up his office,"
The media keeps missing the issue here which is unethically using of federal proceeds to run Sali's campaign, whether its 1) Hoffman wearing two hats 2) siting the offices together in order to get his staff to work on the campaign. 3) federal mailings beyond the date of prohibition madated by the House ethics rules. Its cumulative.
Yes indeed
"But if Ada and Canyon counties continue to grow, relative to the rest of Idaho, the Valley will someday account for half of Idaho's population. When that happens, the Valley should have a standalone congressional district, even if it is one of only two districts in Idaho."
The sooner the better, but count on the majority party to oppose this.
I can't believe your #1 son is in college. Our one-and-only hit ninth grade today. How time flies ...
Don't get a liberal or conservative education for him...
Just get him smart and employed before you are completely broke : )
CARE packages don't go to Africa, after all.